This is a final conclusion by an automobile expert about the comparison of Thar Soft Top (Soft Hood) vs Thar Hard Top. 1. Thar Soft Top (Soft Hood) Advantages: 1. Open-Air Experience – You can easily roll up or remove the soft top for a true jeep feel and enjoy fresh air. 2. Lightweight – Less weight compared to hard top, slightly improving performance and mileage. 3. Cheaper – More affordable to buy and repair than hard top. 4. Adventure Look – Gives that rugged, army-jeep, off-roader vibe. Disadvantages: 1. Less Security – Easy to unzip or cut, so theft risk is higher. 2. Noise – Wind and road noise is much louder inside at high speeds. 3. Weather Protection – Not fully sealed, so dust, water leaks, and heat seep in more. 4. Durability – Soft top material wears out faster, needs replacement every few years. 2. Thar Hard Top Advantages: 1. Better Security – Solid doors and roof provide more protection from theft. 2. Noise Insulation – Cabin is quieter compared to soft hood, especially on highways. 3. Weather Protection – Much better against rain, dust, heat, and cold. 4. Durability – Longer lifespan, no frequent replacement needed. 5. Comfort – Air-conditioning works much better since cabin is sealed. Disadvantages: 1. Less Adventure Feel – Cannot be rolled down or removed easily, so less “open jeep” experience. 2. Heavier – Adds more weight, slightly reducing performance and mileage. 3. Higher Cost – More expensive to buy and repair if damaged. 4. Customization Limitations – Not as flexible for quick modifications as soft top. # Expert Opinion (My Viewpoint) If you are a hardcore off-roader, adventure lover, and want that true jeep feel, then Soft Hood Thar gives unmatched ruggedness and freedom. But if you are using the Thar as a daily drive in city/highways, family use, or long trips, the Hard Top Thar is the practical and smarter choice because of security, comfort, and weather protection. Personally in the initial phase you can go for a soft hood thar, enjoy your adventure trips in few years and once your top gets affected with that natural wear and tear, then you can modify it with the Hard Top Thar—because while the open jeep look is attractive, in Indian conditions (heat, rain, dust, city traffic), practicality, comfort, and security matter much more for everyday use. Thar Soft Top Thar Hard Top Rugged look Adventure feel Open-air experience Premium finish Weather protection Dust & rain resistance Noise insulation Cabin comfort Air-conditioning efficiency Security features Durability Maintenance cost Lightweight design Heavy body structure Customization options Daily driving Off-road thrill Long trips Family comfort Practicality vs adventure Lifestyle vehicle Jeep feel SUV comfort The Mahindra Thar comes in both Soft Top and Hard Top options, each offering a unique lifestyle experience. The Soft Top Thar is perfect for those who love a rugged look, open-air adventure feel, and true jeep thrill during off-road rides, though it compromises on weather protection, noise insulation, and security features. On the other hand, the Hard Top Thar delivers a premium finish, better dust and rain resistance, enhanced cabin comfort, and effective air-conditioning efficiency, making it ideal for daily driving, long trips, and family comfort. While the Soft Top highlights customization options and a lightweight design, the Hard Top offers durability, practicality, and safety, balancing SUV comfort with a bold lifestyle statement. Being an adventure lover, you can opt for a softhood thar and once you finish your adventure trips and jungle safaris then you can get that soft hood converted into a hard-top without any hard feelings ;)